Alan,I like the scene and the overall setting but the light painting in this case makes the foreground seem flat due to the light source being in the same spot as the camera. This leaves most of the foreground objects with no discernible shadows and robs it of any sense of depth. I have noticed this aspect of light painting before but for some reason it really jumps out with this location.
I have not done any MW shots using the composite approach myself but I can see a strong argument for that technique with a scene like this.
Jameel,In addition to what Alan said, given the sky the ground is quite a bit bright. I tried light painting once and since then I either use a single exposure with natural light for the ground or composite taking the ground exposure before it get very dark.
I didn't really think about the lack of shadows until looking at this. I did try this once out in the Bisti but never really liked the shots although I didn't put my finger on why those shots didn't work until looking at this one. I wonder if it would work better if the light painting source were away from where the camera is shooting so you get create some shadows.Alan,
I agree with you but the time I arrived on the scene dictated the light painting this way. I really had no other option with what type of light I had to work with.
Bob
Jim,Very nice Bob. It sounds like you guys arrived after dark. How long were you there?
I am not sure if you had your choice of compositions, but that's a really nice layout with the petrified logs.
Do you have a link for that workshop? If it's only once a year, I will try to carve out some time for next year. That would be a great opportunity.