Another Milky Way

AlanLichty

Moderator
I like the scene and the overall setting but the light painting in this case makes the foreground seem flat due to the light source being in the same spot as the camera. This leaves most of the foreground objects with no discernible shadows and robs it of any sense of depth. I have noticed this aspect of light painting before but for some reason it really jumps out with this location.

I have not done any MW shots using the composite approach myself but I can see a strong argument for that technique with a scene like this.
 

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
In addition to what Alan said, given the sky the ground is quite a bit bright. I tried light painting once and since then I either use a single exposure with natural light for the ground or composite taking the ground exposure before it get very dark.
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
I like the scene and the overall setting but the light painting in this case makes the foreground seem flat due to the light source being in the same spot as the camera. This leaves most of the foreground objects with no discernible shadows and robs it of any sense of depth. I have noticed this aspect of light painting before but for some reason it really jumps out with this location.

I have not done any MW shots using the composite approach myself but I can see a strong argument for that technique with a scene like this.
Alan,
I agree with you but the time I arrived on the scene dictated the light painting this way. I really had no other option with what type of light I had to work with.
Bob
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
In addition to what Alan said, given the sky the ground is quite a bit bright. I tried light painting once and since then I either use a single exposure with natural light for the ground or composite taking the ground exposure before it get very dark.
Jameel,
Like I said in reply to Alan I did not have an option to use another light source or capture the scene before it turn dark. It was either lighting the scene this way or leave it totally dark.
Bob
 

AlanLichty

Moderator
Alan,
I agree with you but the time I arrived on the scene dictated the light painting this way. I really had no other option with what type of light I had to work with.
Bob
I didn't really think about the lack of shadows until looking at this. I did try this once out in the Bisti but never really liked the shots although I didn't put my finger on why those shots didn't work until looking at this one. I wonder if it would work better if the light painting source were away from where the camera is shooting so you get create some shadows.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Very nice Bob. It sounds like you guys arrived after dark. How long were you there?

I am not sure if you had your choice of compositions, but that's a really nice layout with the petrified logs.

Do you have a link for that workshop? If it's only once a year, I will try to carve out some time for next year. That would be a great opportunity.
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
Very nice Bob. It sounds like you guys arrived after dark. How long were you there?

I am not sure if you had your choice of compositions, but that's a really nice layout with the petrified logs.

Do you have a link for that workshop? If it's only once a year, I will try to carve out some time for next year. That would be a great opportunity.
Jim,
We arrived after dark because the rangers clear everyone out of the park between 6:45 and 7:45. During that time we have to be in the designated camp spot, Then it is at least a 20 minute drive to get to the spot and another 20 minutes to hike to a composition.
We were shooting until 1am, however if we wanted to we could have stayed there all night. There were 2 problems with the workshop. First, we had 7 people with maximum of 10 allowed and one instructor. In my opinion, that was too large a group for one instructor. The instructor admitted that he was use to handling only 2-3 students. Second, the participants had varying skill levels and for some of us that just wanted too light paint and shoot we got held up waiting for the instructor to explain every detail to less experience shooters. This caused me to be very frustrated. Finally I got fed up waked too a very different part of the area on my own just to shoot and light paint. Because I was on my own I had limited ability to light paint as my comment above to Alan and Jameel indicated. To make matters worse the instructor was not very organized or helpful. Having said all that we did have free run of the park all night long and I did manage to get some nice sunrise shots at 5am. As for compositions we did get a window of time to check out compositions between 3pm-6pm. This is a very big park so that time was limited to only one area.
I don't have a link but it does appear on the park web site in June every year. It is a nice opportunity just because you have run of the park all night long but I wish I would have spent a day or two hiking all the park too perhaps locate better compositions. If I ever do this again that is what I would do.
Hope this helps,
Bob
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
Here is another version of the milky way with different light painting. Not sure I like this version because of the hot spot on the left but what does everyone else think?

Petrefied forest MW.jpg
 

Kyle Jones

Moderator
I think you have plenty to work with here. I would darken the foreground some, especially the ground. That would balance the scene a little more and if you leave the logs brighter they will stand out and create more of a feeling of depth.

I usually composite images when I light paint. I'll shoot one image for the sky and then light up separate images for the ground. I can then adjust the brightness in the final image by reducing the opacity. You can also color shift the light painting that way too.
 

Kyle Jones

Moderator
You posted the second version while I was writing. I think that one works better, although I agree that taming the hot spots would help.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
The 2nd one is great Bob! Though I like both of them, I think the bottom can be tweaked in either one with a layer mask.

To Kyle's point, when I light paint, which isn't real often, but I overlay the lightpainted ground on top of non light painted ground and then use a brush on low opacity to brush out any hot spots I got, or to use to even out the light painting as it often can be a bit uneven. Or I will use 2 light painted ground layers (they usually are not the same, and then use a mask and a brush to even it out between the two layers.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Very nice Bob. I actually like that it feels like the light source is coming from the right side illuminating the logs and then the Milky Way is born out of that light source. It flows well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob
Top Bottom