From the Bowels

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
From the Bowels of the Earth come forth!

This is from Joshua Tree National Park. After a night of Deep Space Astrophotography I then went to the Arch Rock area and I liked how the rock shapes were playing with the incoming clouds at sunrise. This is pretty much how it looked as shot. Of course I can pull shadow detail out to get the details in the rocks as I saw them in person, but in this case I liked how the camera captured the exposure. It let the ground go dark in order to not blow out the sky.

While processing I did try to pull the detail out of the rocks, but with the hundreds of rocks and boulders that make up this scene I think it ended up distracting then from the outline of the rocks here.

All comments are welcome,

Jim

_D852800_dw.jpg
 

AlanLichty

Moderator
Simple shapes can be good when the goal is to not draw too much attention to their details. Good call on the processing to make the focus the nice sunrise colors.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Simple shapes can be good when the goal is to not draw too much attention to their details. Good call on the processing to make the focus the nice sunrise colors.
Thanks Alan! Though I processed it this way to actually draw focus to the shapes, the clouds and colors pull the eye back to the shapes I think. Anyway, it was the shapes of those rocks that drew my to this composition.
 

Amy Earl

Well-Known Member
Very nice rock silhouettes! I like how you processed this, good thinking. The sky and rock shapes complement each other well.
 

TimMc

Well-Known Member
From the Bowels of the Earth come forth!

...
While processing I did try to pull the detail out of the rocks, but with the hundreds of rocks and boulders that make up this scene I think it ended up distracting then from the outline of the rocks here.
...

View attachment 26243
Great picture. It is really neat to understand the thought behind the processing--Thanks
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Great picture. It is really neat to understand the thought behind the processing--Thanks
Thanks Tim! I have been trying to search for the right words to describe what I saw in that early morning light. Perhaps liquid rock or wave splashes of rock. If the rocks were fluid and they are splashing about while reaching up since both sides angle in to the middle. Almost like someone or something is trying to escape their grasp and the rocks are reaching up and trying to pull them back down.
 

David S

Well-Known Member
nice colors and 2/3 composition! Looks real as opposed to the high HDR people out there...
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
I am not sure Jim about the silhouette version. What about bring out just a faint detail in the rocks? I think I would like to see some detail in the rocks but it just maybe me.
 

Terry Farrow

Well-Known Member
From the Bowels of the Earth come forth!

This is from Joshua Tree National Park. After a night of Deep Space Astrophotography I then went to the Arch Rock area and I liked how the rock shapes were playing with the incoming clouds at sunrise. This is pretty much how it looked as shot. Of course I can pull shadow detail out to get the details in the rocks as I saw them in person, but in this case I liked how the camera captured the exposure. It let the ground go dark in order to not blow out the sky.

While processing I did try to pull the detail out of the rocks, but with the hundreds of rocks and boulders that make up this scene I think it ended up distracting then from the outline of the rocks here.

All comments are welcome,

Jim

View attachment 26243
Beautiful colours with the silhouette of the rocks have made a stunning image Jim.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
I am not sure Jim about the silhouette version. What about bring out just a faint detail in the rocks? I think I would like to see some detail in the rocks but it just maybe me.
Thank you Bob. Perhaps just a bit of detail could work. When I processed this, I went first to full on Shadow Recovery, so the rocks that make up those silhouettes were in full detail and it was immediate that I saw the image lost that magical feeling as the hundreds of rocks making up the ground layer just pulled the eyes too much. Now I did try as you suggested, to see just how much shadow detail would work. And one with just a hint of detail wasn't too bad too my eye, so it could work. In the end I decided to go with what was more or less the SOOC view. But I could work up one with just a bit of shadow recovery for you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob

Bob

Well-Known Member
Thank you Bob. Perhaps just a bit of detail could work. When I processed this, I went first to full on Shadow Recovery, so the rocks that make up those silhouettes were in full detail and it was immediate that I saw the image lost that magical feeling as the hundreds of rocks making up the ground layer just pulled the eyes too much. Now I did try as you suggested, to see just how much shadow detail would work. And one with just a hint of detail wasn't too bad too my eye, so it could work. In the end I decided to go with what was more or less the SOOC view. But I could work up one with just a bit of shadow recovery for you.
Jim,
You could be correct silhouette is better but not knowing this location and not knowing what the ground look like in front leaves me wondering about the foreground. However, that mystery could be just what you want.
Bob
 

rfkiii

Well-Known Member
I was in Joshua Tree in January. I wanted to visit Arch Rock but was not clear about how to access the area. The book I had said the area could be accessed from the campground but the park closed the area to all but those camping there. I drove down about a 1/4 mile to a dirt road and shot sunrise from there. For a full frontal view of the sunrise, that might have been a better place anyway.
 
Top Bottom