Goðafoss

Kyle Jones

Moderator
I've shared an earlier version of this in a Waterfall Wednesday thread a while back, but I spent some time working on it last night and wanted to share.

The falls themselves are impressive, with a great horseshoe shape and lots of vantage points to shoot from. As I framed this, I was trying to get the brighter warm light on the right to contrast with the darker clouds on the left. In my recent rework I opened up the shadows some and tried bringing out some more detail in the sky. Any thoughts are welcome.

4809 Goðafoss_850.jpg
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
I love the sky you ended up with here. Subtle but very nice. The waterfalls stand no matter what. I would try a crop with the bottom rocks removed. They are fine, but I would try.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Yep, I like the work here Kyle. I can see where some darker cloud would add more drama, but this works too. That is one impressive place.
 

Ken Rennie

Well-Known Member
At the great risk of trying to teach grandparents, sexual equality, to suck eggs have you tried to invert the image and make it small ( I use my phone with auto rotate switched off) and see where your eyes go. For me the bright sky is catching my eyes too much. Having said that, it is a lovely image. Ken
 

MonikaC

Well-Known Member
At the great risk of trying to teach grandparents, sexual equality, to suck eggs have you tried to invert the image and make it small ( I use my phone with auto rotate switched off) and see where your eyes go. For me the bright sky is catching my eyes too much. Having said that, it is a lovely image. Ken
I agree with Ken -- the sky looks just about blown out. It's still an iconic location for a reason.
 

Kyle Jones

Moderator
At the great risk of trying to teach grandparents, sexual equality, to suck eggs have you tried to invert the image and make it small ( I use my phone with auto rotate switched off) and see where your eyes go. For me the bright sky is catching my eyes too much. Having said that, it is a lovely image. Ken
I agree with Ken -- the sky looks just about blown out. It's still an iconic location for a reason.
I appreciate your thoughts. I decided to start over from scratch making sure to hold more detail in the sky. Let me know what you think. This may be a little over the top. :)

4809 Goðafoss_850.jpg
 

MonikaC

Well-Known Member
Thanks! I'm a little concerned about the saturation, shadow recovery, etc.
You could back off the saturation in the clouds a bit, but I don't have a problem with it. I think that as a print version (I always brighten 10-20%), it's probably spot on. If I were to compare the 2 & nitpick, I might back off the shadow recovery in the rocks just a touch.
 

Eric Gofreed

Well-Known Member
I've shared an earlier version of this in a Waterfall Wednesday thread a while back, but I spent some time working on it last night and wanted to share.

The falls themselves are impressive, with a great horseshoe shape and lots of vantage points to shoot from. As I framed this, I was trying to get the brighter warm light on the right to contrast with the darker clouds on the left. In my recent rework I opened up the shadows some and tried bringing out some more detail in the sky. Any thoughts are welcome.

View attachment 22518
envy your processing skills, Kyle
 

Bart Carrig

Well-Known Member
Both are very well processed with challenging light; beautiful result. I favor the 2nd version, and agree with Monika, just a little less shadow recovery on the rocks.

Bart
 

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
I prefer the original version between the two. A nice composition with wide view of the falls. The edited version has the sky a little too overpowering. The suggestion foe darkwning the rocks is something I’d second as well.
 
Top Bottom