Original or Pano Crop?

  • #1 - Original

  • #2 - Pano Crop

  • #3 - Not sure


Results are only viewable after voting.

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
It was truly amazing to see the southern end of Joshua Tree so completely carpeted with wildflowers, so much so I drove out there 3 times to shoot them with this being from the final evening last Sunday. The wildflowers were so thick that even as I took extreme care as I moved about in them my brown hiking shoes had turned yellow along with the bottom of my pants.

This is from just past sunset. The clouds had disappeared but the sun even though it was below the horizon was still making it's presence felt. So with the skies now blue I was composing my shots to have the golden glow of the sun radiating out from the corner.

As I was processing this, I was struck by the fact that while normally when there is a clear blue sky I will then crop most of it out, but in this instance I thought that the blue was a great contrast to the colors in the ground. Still, I thought I needed to do a pano crop to lose some of the sky just to see if my normal thought process was valid here or not. Even after cropping, I am not sure. So I am using a poll here to see what you guys think. Please be sure to comment along with voting. :)

All comments are welcome,

Jim

#1 - Original
_D853336_dw.jpg



#2 - Pano Crop
_D853336_pano_dw.jpg
 

AlanLichty

Moderator
Normally I would also crop out naked blue sky but in this case the color gradations along the upper right hand side of the scene compliment the rest of the image nicely. The pano crop takes just a bit of that away.
 

Tom Narwid

Well-Known Member
It was truly amazing to see the southern end of Joshua Tree so completely carpeted with wildflowers, so much so I drove out there 3 times to shoot them with this being from the final evening last Sunday. The wildflowers were so thick that even as I took extreme care as I moved about in them my brown hiking shoes had turned yellow along with the bottom of my pants.

This is from just past sunset. The clouds had disappeared but the sun even though it was below the horizon was still making it's presence felt. So with the skies now blue I was composing my shots to have the golden glow of the sun radiating out from the corner.

As I was processing this, I was struck by the fact that while normally when there is a clear blue sky I will then crop most of it out, but in this instance I thought that the blue was a great contrast to the colors in the ground. Still, I thought I needed to do a pano crop to lose some of the sky just to see if my normal thought process was valid here or not. Even after cropping, I am not sure. So I am using a poll here to see what you guys think. Please be sure to comment along with voting. :)

All comments are welcome,

Jim

#1 - Original
View attachment 16616


#2 - Pano Crop
View attachment 16617
Better.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Normally I would also crop out naked blue sky but in this case the color gradations along the upper right hand side of the scene compliment the rest of the image nicely. The pano crop takes just a bit of that away.
Thanks Alan! I kind of feel the same way but not 100% on it.
 

Mike Lewis

Staff Member
Late to the party and with a contrasting vote, but I prefer the uncropped image. That wonderful blue gradient really works well with the other colors in the sky and the ground, and the pano crop seems to be a little too constraining to me. Perhaps Alan's idea of a lesser crop, but I dunno - I still think the original would be my choice. Lovely problem to have though - it is a crackin' good shot!

ML
 
Top Bottom