Ward Terrace

Bob

Well-Known Member
Hey Everyone,
Here is two images I captured at Ward Terrace last night. I was trying out a new camera and lens. The camera is the Sony a7R4 and the lens was a Rokinon 14 mm f2.8. The jury is still out on weather I am pleased with the results. I could use some comments on the results. These were a 25 second exposure with iso 3200. Comments welcome.
Bob


Ward Terrace milky way-1.jpg


Ward Terrace milky way-2.jpg
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Hey Bob,

It will be interesting to see your conclusions after testing that duo some more. The 14mm was not decentered? It looks good here, but that's it's biggest quality issue when buying one.

I agree that #1 is the better of the two, it has perhaps to taste the better colored sky and Milky Way. It could use a bit more contrast perhaps, maybe making the background sky a tad darker? And the light painting is better in #1. Just tone down the very bottom of the ground a bit to match the light on the background rocks and this one is sweet.

With #2, I like the composition a lot, but like the others the light painting is a bit too strong. It's not too bad to have stronger light painting, but it should be evenly painted. Now granted, that's not an easy task at with a scene like this. I do like that you went for what seems like some directional side lighting, it was just a bit too bright.
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
Hey Bob,

It will be interesting to see your conclusions after testing that duo some more. The 14mm was not decentered? It looks good here, but that's it's biggest quality issue when buying one.

I agree that #1 is the better of the two, it has perhaps to taste the better colored sky and Milky Way. It could use a bit more contrast perhaps, maybe making the background sky a tad darker? And the light painting is better in #1. Just tone down the very bottom of the ground a bit to match the light on the background rocks and this one is sweet.

With #2, I like the composition a lot, but like the others the light painting is a bit too strong. It's not too bad to have stronger light painting, but it should be evenly painted. Now granted, that's not an easy task at with a scene like this. I do like that you went for what seems like some directional side lighting, it was just a bit too bright.
Jim,
Very interesting comments. I try a bit more contrast on #1. With #2 I was trying a whole bunch of different things but that was the best I can do. What do you mean by the comment on the 14mm not being decentered not sure what that means?
Bob
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
That first one is nice. I have a copy of that lens for the Canon mount and works well for MW.
Janeel,
Thank you for your comments. I am not sure I like the 14mm. The advantage it is cheap. Have you tried the Sigma 14mm f1.8 on the canon? I was thinking of getting that one and selling the 14mm.
Bob
 

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
Janeel,
Thank you for your comments. I am not sure I like the 14mm. The advantage it is cheap. Have you tried the Sigma 14mm f1.8 on the canon? I was thinking of getting that one and selling the 14mm.
Bob
No I don't have the Sigma - from all that I have seen, it is a superb lens. The Rokinon is good value for the $$$. It is sharp, has little to no coma. I have a good copy with no decentering and the infinity is spot on. It has quite a bit distortion which doesn't lend itself to things like architecture.
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
No I don't have the Sigma - from all that I have seen, it is a superb lens. The Rokinon is good value for the $$$. It is sharp, has little to no coma. I have a good copy with no decentering and the infinity is spot on. It has quite a bit distortion which doesn't lend itself to things like architecture.
Thanks for the info
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
I have to agree with the others on the first image and the color of the mw. I did one last night with theCanon R5 and a Rokinon 14 F2 I used iso 1600 20 second. I have not been able to review them other than in camera. From your settings I am probably too dark. I like your first one
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
I have to agree with the others on the first image and the color of the mw. I did one last night with theCanon R5 and a Rokinon 14 F2 I used iso 1600 20 second. I have not been able to review them other than in camera. From your settings I am probably too dark. I like your first one
Thanks Ben. I agree with everyone also. I am going to try and reprocess the second to get it darker. I did a lot of light painting and maybe one of the other ones will work better. I would like to hear your opinion on the Rokinon lens. Sigma has a 14 mm f1.8 that I am thinking of getting.
Bob
 

Jim Dockery

Well-Known Member
I agree that the composition in the 2nd is better, but the painting too strong. I'm not a fan of LP in most cases and only when it is very lightly done to look like moonlight, but like Jim said it has to be very even for that to work which seems impossible with distant rocks like you've got here.

I had that lens for my A7rII and got good results but it was too dang big and heavy for me. I got the Zeiss Batis 18mm 2.8 and am happy with it. Have you seen the new Samyang 24mm 1.8? It looks very interesting, but I'll wait for the tests.
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
I agree that the composition in the 2nd is better, but the painting too strong. I'm not a fan of LP in most cases and only when it is very lightly done to look like moonlight, but like Jim said it has to be very even for that to work which seems impossible with distant rocks like you've got here.

I had that lens for my A7rII and got good results but it was too dang big and heavy for me. I got the Zeiss Batis 18mm 2.8 and am happy with it. Have you seen the new Samyang 24mm 1.8? It looks very interesting, but I'll wait for the tests.
Jim,
Unfortunately, I agree I like the composition in the 2nd but the light painting is too strong. When you said the lens was to big and heavy are you referring to the Sigma 14mm? Because the Rokinon 14mm is very small and light weight. Here is a different version of the 2nd image I worked up today.

ward terrace.jpg
 

Mike Koopsen

Well-Known Member
Hi Bob, really love the first Milky Way shot and the second version of the second shot as well. I especially like the compositions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Thanks Ben. I agree with everyone also. I am going to try and reprocess the second to get it darker. I did a lot of light painting and maybe one of the other ones will work better. I would like to hear your opinion on the Rokinon lens. Sigma has a 14 mm f1.8 that I am thinking of getting.
Bob
Hey Bob, I had the Samyang/Rokinon 14mm f2.8, it certainly is sharp. I bought the Sigma 14mm f1.8 as soon as it was released for Nikon, and there is no way I would go back. The extra stop of light is amazing, and I like it’s feel and how it’s way better built the. Samyang. I totally recommend the 14mm Sigma f1.8 as the best Astro lens there is.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
I will add, if someone is on a budget or wanting a backup 14mm, or maybe starting out in WA Astro, then I heartedly support the Samyang 14mm f2.8, as a great into lens, as long as you check for decentering and keep an eye on it. Because I had one that was centered become decentered while out shooting with it up in Glacier.
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
I will add, if someone is on a budget or wanting a backup 14mm, or maybe starting out in WA Astro, then I heartedly support the Samyang 14mm f2.8, as a great into lens, as long as you check for decentering and keep an eye on it. Because I had one that was centered become decentered while out shooting with it up in Glacier.
Jim,
Thanks for your input. I agree I am finding I need the extra stop of light. I bought the Rokinon because it was cheap and just to try it out. However, after using it I am definitely ordering the Sigma F1.8.
 

Graeme F

Well-Known Member
I'm always a bit puzzled as to what colour the sky should be shown at night when taking a milky way shot- is it basically a dark blue or should it be more brown?
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
I'm always a bit puzzled as to what colour the sky should be shown at night when taking a milky way shot- is it basically a dark blue or should it be more brown?
Graeme,
The sky color depends on the light pollution. When close to a city the sky appears with a brown tint because of the yellow in the lights of the city. When out in a true dark sky area the sky is more blue because of the lack of light pollution. I also cooled the sky down a bit because I like it more blue which is more a personal taste. Hope this explanation helps.
 
Top Bottom