Mike Lewis
Staff Member
So this post started out as an honest question on which of these 3 treatments of the same subject worked the best. I guess it is still that, but while I originally thought I was neutral on which of the 3 I liked best, in getting these ready to post (after days of NOT looking at them) I now have a preferential order to the 3. So I decided I will post them from my favorite to least favorite, but still solicit input from the group, as so many more accomplished scenic shooters here. At the end of the day, while it may not impact my feelings about the set, I am sure I will learn something, and that is always a good thing 
Our trip to Dinosaur NM was predictably hot. Very hot. That combined with the long drive and the work of setting up and tearing down for a 2 night trip meant not much chance or energy to hike as far as I would have liked, especially since my wife is currently dealing with some back issues that prevent her from hiking very far at all. As a result, I did not come away with a lot of images I was really excited about. But being a sucker for 'Grand Vista' images, I did come around a bend on a short trail to the following view. The first thing I noticed was that the scenic overlook location was reached by continuing to the left and down, which meant from there with the trees at that location you really could see very little. So I walked back up and tried to work with what I had. These 3 are from 2 images, one of which is presented as a crop of the other one.
1) This is my favorite view, taken as I had walked up as far as I could to get as much in the scene as possible, but trying to keep a little of the foreground in for scale:
2) This is the earlier shot, with some logs in the foreground. I liked the logs, but in retrospect it seems like they take up too much of the scene, as to me (as always) it is the vista that grabbed my eye...
3) And lastly, a crop of number 2 to try to balance the foreground/background a little better, but unfortuntely at the expense of the logs...
Let me know what you think...
ML
Our trip to Dinosaur NM was predictably hot. Very hot. That combined with the long drive and the work of setting up and tearing down for a 2 night trip meant not much chance or energy to hike as far as I would have liked, especially since my wife is currently dealing with some back issues that prevent her from hiking very far at all. As a result, I did not come away with a lot of images I was really excited about. But being a sucker for 'Grand Vista' images, I did come around a bend on a short trail to the following view. The first thing I noticed was that the scenic overlook location was reached by continuing to the left and down, which meant from there with the trees at that location you really could see very little. So I walked back up and tried to work with what I had. These 3 are from 2 images, one of which is presented as a crop of the other one.
1) This is my favorite view, taken as I had walked up as far as I could to get as much in the scene as possible, but trying to keep a little of the foreground in for scale:
2) This is the earlier shot, with some logs in the foreground. I liked the logs, but in retrospect it seems like they take up too much of the scene, as to me (as always) it is the vista that grabbed my eye...
3) And lastly, a crop of number 2 to try to balance the foreground/background a little better, but unfortuntely at the expense of the logs...
Let me know what you think...
ML