Ben,
I have not seen the other version from another night you referenced, but for me, this is my favorite one of these shots you have ever posted. As Jim said, the Moon is the master light painter for the foreground if you get the right amount and this looks absolutely perfect to me. The composition with the Milky Way coming down towards the foreground rock spire makes this very powerful I think. And I think I like the blue tinge to the sky when you are going to show lighted foreground in particular - for whatever reason just looks more natural to me. This is a wall hanger in my book!
What was the date you took this shot?