Comments welcome-Experimental Composition

Tom Narwid

Well-Known Member
When I took this image (Camden, Maine) I thought I would try an "extreme" composition. I have mixed feelings about it....sometimes I like it and sometimes I don't. I would be interested in
how your eyes see it. Please comment. I would love to hear your opinion and how you see it.

Camden, Me-5.jpg
 

AlanLichty

Moderator
It somehow feels incomplete to my eyes. I keep wanting to see more off to the sides of the frame as it exists in the image. I do like the sailboats down at the bottom but would like to see more of them than the frame offers.

Interesting concept but as framed here doesn't really grab me.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Hey Tom, thanks for posting this with the question. It’s always fun and educational to have posts like this because it really makes us think.

I really like what you were going for with this. I think with as it stands, I wish there was just a little more space at the bottom below the sailboats, not much more but a little bit.

With how this is here, my suggestion to perhaps improve as it was shot is to crop the top off just below the land so that’s its only water. I think not having the land and sky give the image then a feeling of infinity, never ending sailing.
 
My brain wants to make the boats larger. It is as if these are toy boats. I think this is because I expect the boats to be more of the main subject.
 

Amy Earl

Well-Known Member
Like Jim, I feel like a little more space to the bottom and right of the sailboats would work better. I'm curious as to whether that strip of land tapers off into the sea in your original image. If it does, it would be nice to try including where it ends and crop a little beyond that to the left. I do like the water trails the sailboats are making going in different directions. If you post the original image it might be easier for us to guage what might look better in terms of the crop you're going for.
 

Tom Narwid

Well-Known Member
Like Jim, I feel like a little more space to the bottom and right of the sailboats would work better. I'm curious as to whether that strip of land tapers off into the sea in your original image. If it does, it would be nice to try including where it ends and crop a little beyond that to the left. I do like the water trails the sailboats are making going in different directions. If you post the original image it might be easier for us to guage what might look better in terms of the crop you're going for.
Like Jim, I feel like a little more space to the bottom and right of the sailboats would work better. I'm curious as to whether that strip of land tapers off into the sea in your original image. If it does, it would be nice to try including where it ends and crop a little beyond that to the left. I do like the water trails the sailboats are making going in different directions. If you post the original image it might be easier for us to guage what might look better in terms of the crop you're going for.
Thanks for your comments. Also, that is the original image and has not been cropped from a larger image.
 
Top Bottom