Cracked Lake Comp Issue

AlanLichty

Moderator
The closer in crop in the second image keeps me more focused on the neat textures in the ice but the first one with the wider view showing the colors of the ground vegetation is equally engaging. Guess I'm not much help for your choice dilemma 😁
 

Jim Dockery

Well-Known Member
That is a tough one - I like seeing the clouds on the right in the first, but the lines in the lake are much more dramatic in the 2nd. If I had to choose I'd go #2. I might select the sky and tame the highlights in it working to bring out the clouds more.
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
I prefer the second image. The larger size of the peaks and the foreground ice cracks make it for me.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Both are great Tim! That's so awesome you have the cracks in the lake! I have yet to get up to Dream Lake and see what kind of cracks or bubbles it might have.

I would give the edge to #2 because I like that leading line shooting out of the bottom of it in the ice pattern.
 

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
Of the two I like #2 for the reasons already mentioned. Ideally I'd like a composition somewhere between the two where the big rock is not cut off.
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
Tim,
I agree with the comments above the leading lines work better on #2.
Bob
 

MonikaC

Well-Known Member
#2 for me, too. I'm on the fence, though, as to whether or not the boulder in the foreground is more of a distraction than addition to the composition.
 

Bob Israel

Well-Known Member
I think I like #2 better but I kind of like the rock and grass in the first. Tough choice as both are winners!
 

Timmeh

Well-Known Member
Thanks for the advice everyone! I had trouble letting go of some parts of #1 partly for what Monika had to say about the rock. However, I think the leading line leads around the rock, and I think there's enough of it to justify its existence in the frame.
 
Top Bottom