Last sunset before Christmas.

AlanLichty

Moderator
A very pleasant scene to view.

No polarizers for sunsets? Rules like that are meant to be broken if it gives you the result you wanted :D

Have a good one.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
I haven't heard anyone say No Polarizers for Sunset, not that I can recall. The Polarizer is our most used tool as a Photographer. Do you remember their reasoning for not wanting to use a polarizer?

Especially around water like here the polarizer can be awesome for deepening the blues and greens of the water. Now sometimes I will back off so that I can make sure the color (if there is color) is then reflecting more off the water. But I usually shoot both in those situations, some with the polarizer adjusted for more reflection and some for less. If I am shooting Wide Angle I will also keep an eye for uneven polarization in the sky and adjust it to lessen that.

Anyway.... :) You really worked that sun very well Terry, I like that Sunstar.

And it's your last sunset before Christmas? We still are not quite there yet. For me it's about 11am on Christmas Eve.
 

Ken Rennie

Well-Known Member
I haven't heard anyone say No Polarizers for Sunset, not that I can recall. The Polarizer is our most used tool as a Photographer. Do you remember their reasoning for not wanting to use a polarizer?

Especially around water like here the polarizer can be awesome for deepening the blues and greens of the water. Now sometimes I will back off so that I can make sure the color (if there is color) is then reflecting more off the water. But I usually shoot both in those situations, some with the polarizer adjusted for more reflection and some for less. If I am shooting Wide Angle I will also keep an eye for uneven polarization in the sky and adjust it to lessen that.

Anyway.... :) You really worked that sun very well Terry, I like that Sunstar.

And it's your last sunset before Christmas? We still are not quite there yet. For me it's about 11am on Christmas Eve.
Jim the most likely reasons for not using a polarizer: firstly more chance of flare but secndly and most importantly the polarizing effect is 0 when looking directly at or 180 degrees from the sun and maximum at 90 degrees from the sun so during a sunset the darkening of the sky will increase the as you look further from the sun thus increasing the contrast in the sky ie the already bright patch close too the sun will not be reduced in brightness but the further you move from this position the darker the sky and the more saturated the colours this is almost exactly the opposite of what we want as we try and control the central brightness. Of course if we have water in the scene then the polarizer will still provide a benefit (Physics 101) Merry Christmas Ken
 

Mike Lewis

Staff Member
Yes, only reason I can think of is like Ken said polarizing effect is minimized into the sun (or directly away from it) and so it becomes basically more like just a ~2 stop ND which is not always helpful at the end of the day.

and P.S. - Love the shot too, btw!

ML
 

Terry Farrow

Well-Known Member
I haven't heard anyone say No Polarizers for Sunset, not that I can recall. The Polarizer is our most used tool as a Photographer. Do you remember their reasoning for not wanting to use a polarizer?

Especially around water like here the polarizer can be awesome for deepening the blues and greens of the water. Now sometimes I will back off so that I can make sure the color (if there is color) is then reflecting more off the water. But I usually shoot both in those situations, some with the polarizer adjusted for more reflection and some for less. If I am shooting Wide Angle I will also keep an eye for uneven polarization in the sky and adjust it to lessen that.

Anyway.... :) You really worked that sun very well Terry, I like that Sunstar.

And it's your last sunset before Christmas? We still are not quite there yet. For me it's about 11am on Christmas Eve.
 

Terry Farrow

Well-Known Member
Thanks for that Jim, I was thinking of the 90 degrees rule which I’d read somewhere about polarised filters but needed something as I don’t have a nd filter and wanted that star effect on the setting sun which seems to have worked.
 

Terry Farrow

Well-Known Member
Yes, only reason I can think of is like Ken said polarizing effect is minimized into the sun (or directly away from it) and so it becomes basically more like just a ~2 stop ND which is not always helpful at the end of the day.

and P.S. - Love the shot too, btw!

ML
Thanks for that Mike I don’t have a ND filter and felt I needed something for this shot. I’ve a thing about trying for star effects as the sun appears or starts to slip behind a mountain or such.
 
Top Bottom