Looking up (added image)

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
From my first trip to the Arches NP. Exposed the sky and arch separately and blended. Just processed it since the attempted blend back a decade or so ago never looked right. This is the familiar double arch.

C&C Welcome

A color version
YI2A3983.jpg


A converted monochrome one
YI2A3934bw.jpg


Here is the color version of the 2nd image.

YI2A3934.jpg
 
Last edited:

MonikaC

Well-Known Member
Your blend worked well. I've never been happy with anything I've gotten from there. I guess there's plenty of time to archive dive....
 

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
Your blend worked well. I've never been happy with anything I've gotten from there. I guess there's plenty of time to archive dive....
Thanks Monika. Without proper light and sky, that area is hard to get good compositions if the focus are the arches themselves. However there are other aspects of this part which lend themselves well.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Hey Jameel,

First to #2 and 3. It's a cool composition, and I think I like the color one best. In the B&W the arch is getting lost a bit in the sky. Maybe darken the blues of the sky even more to help provide separation in the B&W?

#1 is pretty sweet, it's an amazing sight to take in. I do wish the composition had more on the left and less on the right. Though this is really nice as is, that would be my only nit.
 

Amy Earl

Well-Known Member
#1 is amazing, Jameel! Very well processed.

Though I'm a realist and am noticing that the lighting is a bit unrealistic (the underside of the arches would normally be darker looking up in that spot), I like how your processing allows one to appreciate the color and detail of the rock in addition to that of the sky. They look very good together and the composition is pleasing. #3 on the other hand doesn't manage to achieve what #1 does. The unrealistic lighting is somehow making the rock look flat - or perhaps it's the stretched perspective?

Excellent work!
 

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
Hey Jameel,

First to #2 and 3. It's a cool composition, and I think I like the color one best. In the B&W the arch is getting lost a bit in the sky. Maybe darken the blues of the sky even more to help provide separation in the B&W?

#1 is pretty sweet, it's an amazing sight to take in. I do wish the composition had more on the left and less on the right. Though this is really nice as is, that would be my only nit.
Thanks Jim. I struggled with the B&W conversion on the second one a bit on this. I feel the arch is lighter than what I'd like. And of course there needs to be a tonal separation between the arch and the sky. I will play with it a bit. I do like the color one myself.

With #1, I agree. I do have a few more compositions. Given the angle it was shot, I did this hand held.
 

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
#1 is amazing, Jameel! Very well processed.

Though I'm a realist and am noticing that the lighting is a bit unrealistic (the underside of the arches would normally be darker looking up in that spot), I like how your processing allows one to appreciate the color and detail of the rock in addition to that of the sky. They look very good together and the composition is pleasing. #3 on the other hand doesn't manage to achieve what #1 does. The unrealistic lighting is somehow making the rock look flat - or perhaps it's the stretched perspective?

Excellent work!
Thanks Amy.

Your perception of 'unrealistic' light is correct in that this is not a single capture. Metering for the sky would render the arch much darker and metering for the arch would make the sky blow the highlights. This is the reason I took two separate shots thus expanding the DR considerably.
 

Jim Dockery

Well-Known Member
I'm partial to the b&w and disagree that the arch is too light, looks good to me. I might try to darken the sky on the left side a bit more, but also add contrast so the clouds still stand out. The color of the sky in the others looks a tad green/yellow on my monitor so I'd play with the color balance a bit, although what you've posted may be closer to the sunset color. In any case you've beaten me - I've never been happy with any of my shots from this area.
 

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
I'm partial to the b&w and disagree that the arch is too light, looks good to me. I might try to darken the sky on the left side a bit more, but also add contrast so the clouds still stand out. The color of the sky in the others looks a tad green/yellow on my monitor so I'd play with the color balance a bit, although what you've posted may be closer to the sunset color. In any case you've beaten me - I've never been happy with any of my shots from this area.
Thanks. Good suggestions Jim. The B&W is not (yet) my forte. I plan to tinker with it a bit more.
 
Top Bottom