Moonlit Butte

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
I drove towards Factory Butte looking for a place to get off the road for the nights camp. As you approach the butte, you see a pinnacle half way between the road and the butte. As you come adjacent to this pinnacle you find an unmarked road that takes you to it. At the end, you climb a small hill and find a nice flat area for parking., The pinnacle (I call it the nib) is about 200 yards from here and maybe an 80 foot climb up easy paths. This view is just a few feet from the pinnacle.

As I was going to sleep, I noticed the full moon was making the butte very bright so I got dressed and hiked up for some images.

My aim in this sort of picture is to get enough light on the subject to show lots of color and detail. The sky is secondary. So I thought the best comp was at 50mm a bit long for a night shot. This is 50mm f8 Iso 6400 and 15 seconds, so a bit of star motion is present.

200505-12690-5DS R copy.jpg



This one is a more traditional night shot at 24mm iso 400 f5.6 and 15 seconds.

200505-12688-5DS R.jpg
 

Jim Dockery

Well-Known Member
I prefer the second one. I also see some nice faint clouds that you might be able to tease out more. Like Jeffrey I've driven by, but never went off the Hwy toward Factory. For sure next time.
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
Thanks guys, but be careful. As I drove up it was dark and I nearly drove off the hill I was driving. The road follows the ridge of these hills and is just wide enough for a vehicle. It has an abrupt right turn at the end and I nearly went straight.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Hey Ben,

I am liking #1 a lot. I like that in close view of Factory Butte, it sure stands nice and proud there. #2 is really nice too, but for me, I really like #1 as those ridges along the butte really stand out.

I would suggest 2 things.

First in #2, I would clone out that vapor trail by the moon.

In both, even though your goal wasn't to get stars, I would make the stars pop more. You have a really dark sky so it would be easy.

Just duplicate the Layers twice in Photoshop.

On the top layer draw a selection that goes just below the top of the Butte, but on both sides angle up some to keep the selection in the darker part of the sky. (You are doing that to keep the brighten of the stars to just the darker part of the sky so the lighter part of the sky along the horizon doesn't get brightened) Create a Layer mask from that Selection. (Press Alt and click on the Create Layer Mask Icon)

Select the Middle Layer. Zoom in closer so you can see the stars, maybe 100%.

In the Selection Menu use Color Range and click inside a star. Then adjust the Fuzziness to somewhere around 100, but do it to taste.

In the Selection Menu go to Modify then to Expand, and Expand by 1 Pixel.

Go back to Normal view on the image so you can see the whole image.

Click on the bottom layer. Go to the Edit menu, select Layers. Now raise up the brightness of that bottom layer until you see the stars a little better.

Make sure to keep it natural looking, you can over do it and the stars will be too bright and look fake. The stars can get lost in a photo, where in person it's easy for us to see them. So this is an easy way to help the viewer who wasn't there to also experience the stars.
 

Bob

Well-Known Member
Ben,
Both shots are nice. I like #1 the best. I also like Jim's suggestion. I never thought of doing that and I will have to try it.
Bob
 

Amy Earl

Well-Known Member
These are stunning images, Ben. I love both of them. Your photo captures the desert night atmosphere that I recall when camping somewhere near Red Rock Canyon. An almost eerie, magical environment that left a lasting impression on me.

I would also be curious to see a version of #1 cropping a lot of sky off the top in order to appreciate the grandeur of the moonlit butte.
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
I tried it but there seems to be a missing step between selecting a star and making the next selection.
 

Bart Carrig

Well-Known Member
Wonderful images Ben. I really like them both, but like Jim, have a hankerin' for the first.

Thanks for the star tips, Jim, I'll be checking the tutorial.

Bart
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
Jim, I had some more issues. For one thing, even at 400% the stars are too small for a selection. Maybe this works better at wider focal lengths. I will try it on my 24mm shot. But there is another issue. I can't figure out how to get from the first selection to the second one. For example, after you do color range, you say go into the selection menu and expand. But if I just go to select I lose the color range selection.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Hey Ben, the only way to lose what you have selected is by clicking on the screen with the Selection tool.

Are you trying to click on a white star? I can see them by eye on your jpg, so you definitely should see them at 100%.

Send me a dng in a conversation and let me look at your 50mm shot. At 50mm your stars should be bigger then at 24 or 14.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
If you still have problems, post your 50mm in Critique and let’s work on it in there.
 
Top Bottom