This is a 4x5 crop, and I think square would be the crop you describe. I have a number of other compositions that I tried, and this one worked the best for my eye. I have a landscape orientation, no sky, with the sun below the horizon, and none of those worked for me. Here's close to the crop you suggested.Hey Tim,
I like what you were going for. Getting S Curves along the Owens River gets harder and harder each year as more trees and bushes grow up around it. So this is a nice spot. I would suggest cropping off almost all of the sky though, cut the sun in half maybe. It's so bright in the sky, my eye is getting pulled away from the S curve and feeling blinded. Going with a 4:5 crop may be the way to go.