Tatoosh Sunset

Amy's wonderful layer images inspired me to go back and look through my archives to find an image I took of sunset of the Tatoosh Range in Mt. Rainier National Park in 1994. This image has special meaning to me because it taught me some great lessons about judges and people in general who evaluate your work. This was the first image I ever entered in a competition and it won best of show. So I entered it into another competition and it didn't even get an honorable mention. I was very perplexed until I realized that judging images is very subjective. I eventually became a judge of competitions and learned even more of how differently we all look at photographs.

tatoosh IV.jpg
 
Last edited:

Jim Dockery

Well-Known Member
Nice one, like Jameel I've got a few of the same sunset view. BTW, the small Tatoosh Range is south of this view. I don't know what that cool cone shaped hill in the center is called.
 
Last edited:

Mike Lewis

Staff Member
Doug,

Great image - the colors and the layering are special.

Your comments about judging are spot on too - I have discovered over the years for my own work that while I can easily identify the images of mine that I like the best, there is typically very little correlation to which images might get recognition elsewhere. And then, if something does get recognized once, it may go completely unnoticed when evaluated by another person or group. It really does bring out the fact that everyone brings a different eye to each and every image they see and respond to.

ML
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Wow, I can see this one being a Best of Show Doug! What a super cool image.

@Tex Schneider is our local master of the Art Shows as he get's lot's of Best of Shows and other awards. I was entering too for 5 or 6 years and always won something each year except for the last year. Never Best of Show but still got some awards. I made it a practice to go through the Art show each year as it was help as part of our OC Fair here in Orange County. After the 2nd or 3rd year without trying to be or sound mean I realized these judges had no credibility. One can say it's all in the eye of the beholder, but let's be honest there are some really great photos that are just great and there are some really bad photos that are really bad! The middle ground is what it is, you can't really argue on them much.

But what I started noticing each year is that yeah, a lot of great photos did get awards. But I would venture to say 40% of those getting awards were "Bad" photos and almost always hanging on the wall right next to it would be an awesome photo with great light, composition, emotion, etc.. And that awesome photo got nothing, not even an honorable mention.

So as you can tell I got soured on these Art shows, at least the one at the OC Fair. I still enjoy going to look at all of the photos, and my neck get's lot's of exercise as I am shaking it "no" a lot at those badly composed, exposed and focused photos that when 1st in a Category still.
 

dan swiger

Well-Known Member
Amy's wonderful layer images inspired me to go back and look through my archives to find an image I took of sunset of the Tatoosh Range in Mt. Rainier National Park in 1994. This image has special meaning to me because it taught me some great lessons about judges and people in general who evaluate your work. This was the first image I ever entered in a competition and it won best of show. So I entered it into another competition and it didn't even get an honorable mention. I was very perplexed until I realized that judging images is very subjective. I eventually became a judge of competitions and learned even more of how differently we all look at photographs.

View attachment 27446
Doug, love this collection of layers & colors. It "almost" looks like a painting
 

Tex Schneider

Ambassador
I love the layers in this image. Yes, it is very worthy of entering in a show.

Jim is too kind about me and awards. Basically, I just enter the Orange County Fair Visual Arts competition each year. Like, Jim, I really enjoy going down there each year and looking at all of the amazing images on the walls.
 
Nice one, like Jameel I've got a few of the same sunset view. BTW, the small Tatoosh Range is south of this view. I don't know what that cool cone shaped hill in the center is called.
I just pulled up Google Earth and it looks like it is Mt. Wow, Jim. I'm not sure why I didn't realize I wasn't looking at the Tatoosh Range because it is obviously to the south of the parking area at Paradise Lodge which is where this image was made. Thanks for the heads up, Jim.
 
Doug,

Great image - the colors and the layering are special.

Your comments about judging are spot on too - I have discovered over the years for my own work that while I can easily identify the images of mine that I like the best, there is typically very little correlation to which images might get recognition elsewhere. And then, if something does get recognized once, it may go completely unnoticed when evaluated by another person or group. It really does bring out the fact that everyone brings a different eye to each and every image they see and respond to.

ML
Thanks so much, Mike.
 
Wow, I can see this one being a Best of Show Doug! What a super cool image.

@Tex Schneider is our local master of the Art Shows as he get's lot's of Best of Shows and other awards. I was entering too for 5 or 6 years and always won something each year except for the last year. Never Best of Show but still got some awards. I made it a practice to go through the Art show each year as it was help as part of our OC Fair here in Orange County. After the 2nd or 3rd year without trying to be or sound mean I realized these judges had no credibility. One can say it's all in the eye of the beholder, but let's be honest there are some really great photos that are just great and there are some really bad photos that are really bad! The middle ground is what it is, you can't really argue on them much.

But what I started noticing each year is that yeah, a lot of great photos did get awards. But I would venture to say 40% of those getting awards were "Bad" photos and almost always hanging on the wall right next to it would be an awesome photo with great light, composition, emotion, etc.. And that awesome photo got nothing, not even an honorable mention.

So as you can tell I got soured on these Art shows, at least the one at the OC Fair. I still enjoy going to look at all of the photos, and my neck get's lot's of exercise as I am shaking it "no" a lot at those badly composed, exposed and focused photos that when 1st in a Category still.
I agree with everything you said about Fair photo shows. The judges are just terrible. I have no idea where they get them except maybe local camera clubs. The local Sedona Camera Club used to hire outside judges for their local competitions. I was one of their judges and so was Tom Narwid and Derek Von Briesen. I even went to the extent in one competition to take their images and reprocess and recompose them to show them how they could improve. They seemed to really like that but just after that they decided they would judge their own competitions. Now Eric, who is still a member, sometimes doesn't even get an award on his incredible bird images and that is disgusting.
 
Thanks, Tex. I can see that you won a bunch of awards on the picture above and to the left of your head. It would be neat if you posted it here so we could all see it.
 
Top Bottom