Wasatch Spring

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Hey Ben,

That is beautiful! Love all of those flowers in the foreground! The shot looks great to me, I wouldn't say it was overcooked.
 

JaneG

Well-Known Member
lovely foreground but a little over done, do you feel that this image reflects the scene you saw.. the mid and distance are bit grainy and noisy ( oversharpened?), I would go gently and allow the atmospheric effects that soften the scene into the distance have their way. I think it might give a greater feeling of depth and atmsophere
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
lovely foreground but a little over done, do you feel that this image reflects the scene you saw.. the mid and distance are bit grainy and noisy ( oversharpened?), I would go gently and allow the atmospheric effects that soften the scene into the distance have their way. I think it might give a greater feeling of depth and atmsophere
Thanks Jane for the thoughtful and honest reply. I am not sure what the scene looked like to others, but to my dim old eyes it did not look as sharp or clear as I wanted. I asked this question because I suspect I am over cooking to compensate for poor vision. I tend to reduce atmospherics as a result. I will take a closer look at this. I was thinking about saturation, had not considered clarity.
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
Ohhh I would love to be there in the spring~gorgeous! Doesn't look overcooked to me!
Thanks Darcy, it is very nice there.

Hey Ben,

That is beautiful! Love all of those flowers in the foreground! The shot looks great to me, I wouldn't say it was overcooked.
Thanks Jim, most seem ok with it other than Jane who maybe put her finger on the cause for asking.

Nice flowers - makes a great scene even better.

Exactly, and even though this is close to home the window is mere days, makes me appriciate why I seldom hit paydirt on my longer trips.


Lovely image. The foreground flowers lead up to the mountains in the distance.
I knew they would be there and thought this aspen would be great in fall, but the fa;l; after taking this I missed. This year I did better.
 

Jim Dockery

Well-Known Member
Very nice, not overcooked IMO, I also don't see the over sharpening Jane mentions. Did you use a ND at capture? The mountains and clouds look just a tad too dark compared to the slopes below to my picky eye. When used at capture that truly cooks the effect into a shot which is why I personally gave up on ND filters a few years ago after seeing how much DR my Sony cameras have which allows me to adjust the RAW files to compensate most of the time.
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
Very nice, not overcooked IMO, I also don't see the over sharpening Jane mentions. Did you use a ND at capture? The mountains and clouds look just a tad too dark compared to the slopes below to my picky eye. When used at capture that truly cooks the effect into a shot which is why I personally gave up on ND filters a few years ago after seeing how much DR my Sony cameras have which allows me to adjust the RAW files to compensate most of the time.
I also sold all my ND grads, too much witness line and color cast. I did use a grad filter in ACR to darken the sky. I could tone that down easily.
 

lionking

Well-Known Member
Beautiful scenery!
I like it, Jane has a good point, and i agree with Jim Dockery regarding the clouds, if i may add, the flowers pop a bit too much, perhaps less contrast, and i would probably remove those cut-offs buds...
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
Here is one I did later with minimal post processing. Not sure it address all comments as the sky is still darkish from the grad applied in ACR, but less clarity and pop. I would need to reset my ACR conversion for more change.

160702-5718-5DS- R minimum.jpg
 
Top Bottom