Winter water (Image added)

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
As Alan said, it stays pretty dark in some canyons, especially in winter. This is from yesterday. I wanted a longer shutter, but because these were at longer focal lengths, I needed to keep the aperture up. The last one here I resorted to ISO200 to maintain 1/8 at f9.

Like to hear which is your favorite and any other comments.
181219-9310-5DS R.jpg
181219-9313-5DS R.jpg
181219-9328-5DS R.jpg


Added darker version of 2.
181219-9313-5DS RGam85.jpg
 
Last edited:

AlanLichty

Moderator
Fun set - almost surprised there is no ice visible. My preference is the first one mostly because of the way the fallen logs are framed. The first and second ones are close but I like the composition with the little bit more of the log on the right hand side showing and the increased color/light separation of the logs from the water flowing below.
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
Thanks Alan, There was ice, but none in the comps I show. I also prefer the first except the water is more blurred than I like. The second was the closest shot I had with better water speed, but was a tighter framing.
 

Tom Narwid

Well-Known Member

AlanLichty

Moderator
Thanks Alan, There was ice, but none in the comps I show. I also prefer the first except the water is more blurred than I like. The second was the closest shot I had with better water speed, but was a tighter framing.
Fully agree on the water textures in the second shot - much better definition in the second one. I still like the slightly different composition with the logs in the first one.
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
Good idea Alan. Might be a while before I can get back up there with the holidays and visitors. A good snow storm makes this place inaccessible.
 

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Hey Ben, these look like fun. It's hard to pick a favorite, perhaps #2.

As for you resorting to ISO 200, it sounds like that would be a bad thing with your using the word resorting. I personally shoot a lot of my photos at ISO 400 to 800. I choose the ISO I need for the conditions I am in with rarely ever having a regret. 10 to 12 years ago, that was an issue, but not anymore with our camera's. At least for me, the ISO quality now is awesome, and I don't let the ISO restrict what and how I want to shoot. You could have easily shot this at ISO 400 I would think and still have a very high quality image. :)
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
Hey Ben, these look like fun. It's hard to pick a favorite, perhaps #2.

As for you resorting to ISO 200, it sounds like that would be a bad thing with your using the word resorting. I personally shoot a lot of my photos at ISO 400 to 800. I choose the ISO I need for the conditions I am in with rarely ever having a regret. 10 to 12 years ago, that was an issue, but not anymore with our camera's. At least for me, the ISO quality now is awesome, and I don't let the ISO restrict what and how I want to shoot. You could have easily shot this at ISO 400 I would think and still have a very high quality image. :)
Hey Jim, what can I say, old habits die hard. In film days I normally shot ISO25. For this I was unprepared. I should have had my CPL, but left it in the truck. I also left my release cable there, but since I use the timer, it did not really matter. It had been over a month since I was out and I was using a new carry system so I was just messed up.

I like the second one the best, Ben.
Thanks Douglas. I am mixed myself. Fact is even slightly faster on 2 might have been better.
 

Jeffrey

Well-Known Member
I like #1 best, Ben.

Like Jim said, you can use ISO up to 800 with no problems at all. Really gives you the flexibility you need in some situations.
 

Kyle Jones

Moderator
To me the compositions of the first two are close enough that I'd pick the second with it's better water detail. I'd be tempted to darken it a little so it looks a little more like the first
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
To me the compositions of the first two are close enough that I'd pick the second with it's better water detail. I'd be tempted to darken it a little so it looks a little more like the first
Ok, Kyle, I added a new one per your suggestion.
 

AlanLichty

Moderator
I like the edit - much nicer and I don't miss the extra amount of log now. A wider frame is still a thought if you manage to get back up there again :)
 
Top Bottom