#3 for me too for the same reasons as you and Jim - I love sun and clouds. The sunrays shining down on that very interesting and busy distant horizon are what adds the real wow factor and anchor point for the magnificent sky. Topping it all off is the vibrant green grass at the bottom. I'm not religious but this is really like the image we have of Paradise with its blend of blue sky, sea, green hills, warm sunrays -- and a rainbow!
That said, #1 is a strong contender for first place. It's a strong composition and better than #2 because you've drawn focus to the sunrays with the deeper contrast and the darker foreground - the eye is naturally led to the lighter area of the image.
#2 - I totally agree with Alan's crop suggestion. I think either cropping some off the bottom or the top can work (one or the other but not both). In other words, lose the blue sky but keep the flower, or lose the flower and keep the sky. I think I would prefer the latter, and in that case it might even be better than #1 because the clouds are more interesting (especially those little golden ones off to the right). But for this to truly contend with #1 you would also need to darken the foreground a little and enrich the golden rays like you did for #1.
#4 - I love this image, it's a great composition and works so well in b&w. The lone tree in the lower right perfectly complements the pool of light and sunrays on the upper left. I agree with Jim's crop suggestion now that I consider it - that would definitely improve this comp!